If a job turns into a real dispute, there are three ways it gets settled: mediation, arbitration, or court. They differ hugely in cost, speed, and how final they are, and here is the catch most contractors miss: your contract usually decides which one you are stuck with. So the time to understand them is before you sign, not after the fight starts.
Mediation
A neutral person sits both sides down and helps you reach a deal. It is not binding, nobody forces an outcome, and you only settle if you both agree. It is the cheapest and fastest of the three, it keeps the relationship civil, and it works more often than people expect. Many contracts require you to at least try it first.
Arbitration
A private judge, called an arbitrator, hears both sides and makes a binding decision. It is more private and usually faster than court, but the decision is close to final, with very limited right to appeal, and it can get expensive because you help pay the arbitrator. A lot of construction contracts require arbitration instead of court, which means you are agreeing, when you sign, to give up your day in the regular court system.
Court (litigation)
The public court system. Slowest and most expensive, but you get the full process, including a real right to appeal. For smaller amounts, small claims is the fast, cheap version of court, usually with no lawyer needed.
Small claims, and the three things that decide whether it fits
- The dollar limit is the first gate. Every state sets its own, and they are not close to each other. Check yours with the Small Claims check or on your state's page in Working in Your State before you plan around it.
- Some states keep lawyers out of it on purpose. In several, attorneys are barred or restricted in small claims, which is the point: it keeps a one-van outfit on level ground with a customer who has a lawyer on retainer. In others they are allowed. That single difference changes who has the advantage in the room, so find out which yours is.
- Suing as a business is not the same as suing as yourself. States differ on whether an LLC or corporation can be represented by its owner or must send an attorney. If you formed an entity, check that before you file, not on the morning of the hearing.
And the part nobody warns you about: a judgment is not money. Winning gets you a piece of paper saying you are owed. Collecting on it is a separate job, and against a customer who will not pay voluntarily it can mean garnishment or a lien on their property, with its own filing and its own cost. That is exactly why, when the fight is about an unpaid construction bill, the lien usually beats the lawsuit: it attaches to the property itself rather than depending on someone choosing to pay you.
The clause that decides it for you
Your contract has a dispute-resolution clause, and it tells you which of these paths you are locked into. Read it before you sign. If it forces binding arbitration, know exactly what you are giving up. This is one of the most important clauses in the whole contract and most people skip right over it.
Who pays for what
The forums do not just differ in speed. They differ in who is funding the process while it runs, and that is usually what decides whether a small contractor can afford to be right.
- Mediation. One neutral, usually a shared fee, usually a day or less. Cheap enough that it is worth trying even when you expect it to fail, because the failed mediation still tells you what the other side actually wants.
- Arbitration. You are paying a share of a private decision-maker's time plus a filing fee, and unlike a judge, the arbitrator is not free. On a modest dispute the process can cost a meaningful fraction of the amount in dispute, which is the reason a well-drafted arbitration clause is a good thing on a large contract and a trap on a small one.
- Court. Filing fees are comparatively small; the lawyers are not. Small claims is the version where that cost mostly disappears.
Then there is the clause that changes the arithmetic of all three: prevailing-party attorney fees. If your contract says the loser pays the winner's legal costs, a claim that was not worth chasing suddenly is, because your own fees come back if you win. It cuts both ways, which is exactly why it belongs in a contract you have read rather than one you signed at a kitchen table. The contract that protects you (and the one that gets you sued) covers how to write it and what it costs you when you lose.
And an arbitration award is not money either. It is a decision. If the other side does not pay it, you generally still have to take it to a court to be confirmed into a judgment before you can enforce it, and then collect on that. Budget for the whole road, not the hearing.
The move
- Read the dispute clause before you sign, every time.
- When you can, try mediation first. It is cheap and it preserves a working relationship.
- If the fight is simply about money you are owed, a mechanic's lien or small claims is often faster and cheaper than any formal dispute process.
- Start the clock work on day one, in parallel. Do not work down the list one step at a time.
The dispute process does not pause your deadlines
This is the mistake that costs contractors the most money in this whole area, and it does not feel like a mistake while you are making it. Mediation is reasonable. Arbitration is orderly. Both of them take weeks or months, and your mechanic's lien deadline is set by statute and is not listening. It runs from a date on the job, not from the state of your negotiation, and nobody in the mediation is going to remind you about it.
So treat the deadlines and the dispute process as two tracks that run at the same time:
- Get your state's lien deadline for this job on the calendar the day the dispute starts, from the mechanic's lien deadline tool.
- Preserve the right first, then negotiate. Filing or noticing to protect a deadline is not an aggressive act and it does not stop you mediating the next week. Losing the right because you were being polite is not recoverable.
- If the dispute is about unpaid money rather than about the quality of the work, work the payment ladder in Not been paid? Here's your ladder of options alongside whatever the contract makes you do. How to write a demand letter that actually gets you paid is often the whole dispute resolution you need, and it is cheaper than all three forums put together.
Common questions
Can I be forced into arbitration instead of going to court?
Yes. If you signed a contract with a binding arbitration clause, you generally gave up your right to the regular court system for that dispute, and those clauses are usually enforceable once signed. That is why the dispute-resolution clause is one of the most important lines in the whole contract and one most people skip. Read it before you sign, and if it forces arbitration, know you are agreeing up front to a private decision with almost no right to appeal.
Is small claims court cheaper than arbitration?
Usually yes. Small claims is the fast, low-cost version of court, often with no lawyer needed, while arbitration can get expensive because you help pay the arbitrator's fees. For a straightforward "I am owed money" fight under your state's small-claims limit, small claims is frequently the cheapest path of all. The dollar limit varies by state, so check the Small Claims tool for yours before you decide which route fits.
What is the difference between mediation and arbitration?
Mediation is a non-binding, facilitated negotiation where a neutral person helps you reach a deal you both agree to; arbitration is binding, where a private judge hears both sides and imposes a decision you are stuck with. Mediation only settles if both sides say yes, so nobody can force an outcome on you. Arbitration takes the decision out of your hands and is close to final. Many contracts require you to try mediation first before arbitration or court.
Can I skip mediation if my contract requires it?
No, not safely. If your contract makes mediation a required first step, skipping it can jeopardize your right to arbitrate or sue and can get your case thrown out or paused until you do it. Courts and arbitrators take these "conditions precedent" seriously. If the clause says mediate first, mediate first, and it is usually the cheapest and fastest option anyway, so it is rarely worth fighting.
The honest bit
- Which forum applies depends on your contract and the amount, and arbitration clauses are generally enforceable once you have signed.
- This is general guidance, not legal advice. For a large or complex dispute, get a construction attorney involved early, ideally before you are locked into a process.
Know someone who needs this?
Keep reading
Templates you might need
Was this guide useful?
Didn't find what you were looking for?
Spotted something wrong or out of date? Email us at hello@kilnguides.co.uk.
In crisis? 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline 988 ·